Skip to main content

YA Lit.: Dumplin'



Nowadays, young adult literature covers a wide range of themes, offering commentary on everything from self-image and confidence to abuse and death. While the recent release of the Netflix series (based on the novel) 13 Reasons Why  has arguably created a negative association between young adults and literature, there are plenty of YA novels that deal with teenage realities beyond suicide.

Julie Murphy's Dumplin', a novel full of southern charm and the narrator Willowdean's no non-sense sarcasm, provides the reader with a classic battle between feeling good in your own skin and wanting to fit in with society's bodily expectations. Willowdean, an overweight 11th grader in a town obsessed with an annual beauty pageant, can't seem to get away from the local pressures to be a beauty queen. Usually comfortable in her skin, Willowdean starts to question her confidence when a co-worker shows romantic interest. Although dealing with a serious topic that could easily turn into a downward spiral of self-harm and eating disorders, Murphy's protagonist handles her struggles in a way that is more empowering than depressing.

Currently, I am halfway through Dumplin', and while I have trouble buying into the realism behind some of Murphy's characters and their choices, I have enjoyed Willowdean's journey in rebuilding her self-confidence thus far. Exhibiting a gradual increase in risky behavioral choices, it is clear that Willowdean is struggling with a desire for risk and reward that stems from cognitive changes during adolescence. As a result, it is easy for a young adult reader to relate to her thought process and reasoning.

However, the main love interest, Bo, is sometimes less than believable. With an aggressive past, creepy tendencies, no respect for boundaries, and a stereotypical bad-boy heartthrob appearance; Bo is otherwise a mystery to Willowdean and the reader. Bo tends to make choices I would never associate with a popular-ish teen male, and his pursuit of Willowdean despite her larger size seems unrealistic for high school. Unfortunately, societal standards have conditioned Willowdean to be just as skeptical as the reader.

With half the novel to go, I look forward to seeing how the rest of the story unfolds. Will Murphy's characters take a more realistic turn? Hopefully so. The story is full of positive messages about respecting yourself, and if the characters take on more realistic traits by the end, I will not hesitate to recommend the novel for use in a secondary classroom.

Comments

  1. mbFebruary 4, 2018 at 3:59 AM

    Very interesting and thoughtful perspective. I especially appreciate your critical perspective. Well done.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amy GagliardiFebruary 8, 2018 at 10:43 AM

    I like that you are open to being critical about the novel, as well as finding aspects that you enjoy. I wonder how you would use this novel in the classroom if it is not entirely realistic? Would this have an effect on the students?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kayla CarewMarch 14, 2018 at 4:45 PM

    Hi, Allie! As you know, I also read Dumplin', so it was nice to hear your perspectives in greater depth. I, too, thought that the book lacked a sense of realism. After finishing the novel, does your opinion on this issue stand or has it changed? Do you think that Julie Murphy purposefully made the reader view the characters and circumstances as unrealistic to push preconceptions?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Teaching Alternatives: Book Reports

As a part of my elementary school's annual community-building program, students in all grades (which, for us, meant Kindergarten through 5th Grade) were asked to read the same short novel at home. Now, I know that sounds odd, considering the average kindergartener is likely at a lower reading level than the average fifth grader. However, with the option to have your parent or guardian read the story with you at home, I assure you that I was able to make it through some higher level reading with little trouble. By participating in year-round activities as a whole school, students were able to relate to each other across grade levels, all because they had read the same book and had followed the same characters. I will never forget how excited I was when I won a dictionary (Yes, a dictionary... I'd be less excited now, too) for answering the most trivia questions correctly about The Seven Wonders of Sassafras Springs . Though, if I had one complaint about the school- wide
1 comment
Read more

Place-Based Learning: Museums and the Importance of Physical Space in Middle School Education

Before there were formalized schools, there were living rooms, church halls, back steps, battlefields, and the great outdoors. Education came in all shapes and sizes, from the modern understanding of “traditional” study through the analysis of past writings and artifacts to the natural signals one learned to recognize on the farm before an approaching storm. Students were not just young people hunched over a book shielded from the world behind brick walls. They were citizens learning how to manage a family business, reading and printing newspapers, planting seeds, plowing land, and striving to better prepare themselves for the future, whatever it held for them. Today’s students aim to do the same. Yet their education seems to have restricted itself to the boundaries of school property, or perhaps it occasionally wanders beyond county lines. What happened to learning about your environment— and all the life that lived and lives within it— by experiencing everything it has to offer fir
7 comments
Read more

Troublemakers, by Carla Shalaby

Out of any word in the English language, I think I am most intimidated by “power.” It is full of contradictions: Power provokes a sense of accomplishment while implying the achievement and maintenance of power requires competition, hierarchy, and domination. Power is given and taken easily, and it yields to external factors beyond its control. Some people fear power, others are generous with it, and still more meet their doom when pride becomes its companion. Power allows for advancement. It provides a sense of order and control, but it can also create and fuel chaos. Individuals, groups, small islands, and large nations all possess a certain degree of power. As a future educator, the environment of my classroom will depend entirely on how I and my students handle the power we are given in our teacher-student relationships. More importantly, my power as a potential change-maker in their lives— through traditional lessons, personal relationships, worldly guidance, and honest compassion
4 comments
Read more